2025 Silent Capital Report now available. Where family offices and LPs are actually deploying. [Download for free →]

Above the Crowd, Venture Capital Red Flag Checklist

Gurley, prompted by the FTX bankruptcy filing and John Ray III's description of it as the most complete governance failure of his career, distills a ten-item checklist investors should watch for in private companies, opening with frothy bull markets themselves as a risk factor, since heated fundraising environments make investors more willing to overlook weak governance and more likely to be viewed skeptically for raising concerns. Core structural red flags include a board that is missing, packed with friends, or otherwise not functioning as a genuine fiduciary body, early-stage dual-class voting structures that let a single shareholder replace the entire board at will, waived annual audit requirements despite being standard in most Series A term sheets, and financial reporting built around company-invented metrics that cannot be reconciled with traditional accounting. Additional warning signs include atypical corporate counsel or an unusual corporate domicile chosen for lax regulation, outsized secondary share sales by founders that suggest insider knowledge the buyer lacks, a founder simultaneously running another company with overlapping or competing interests, which Gurley calls an absolute non-starter, and a broader climate where founders, investors, press, and politicians all convince themselves a company represents a paradigm shift immune to ordinary business scrutiny.

Why is relevant?

Investors conducting diligence get a genuinely practical, prioritized checklist to actually run against a prospective deal, rather than a vague sense that fraud is hard to spot, with the explicit caution that no single item alone signals malfeasance but that accumulating three or more items sharply raises the probability of a real problem. The framing of frothy bull markets themselves as a governance risk factor is a genuinely useful, self-aware observation for investors to apply to their own behavior, since it names the exact psychological dynamic, fear of looking out of touch by raising concerns, that leads sophisticated investors to wave through weak governance during hot fundraising periods. Founders building their own company from scratch get a concrete list of governance practices to proactively adopt, a real board, standard audits, conventional financial reporting, and reputable counsel, that signal trustworthiness to future investors, functioning as a practical complement to the NVCA model documents already in this archive that formalize many of these same governance norms.
Above the Crowd, Venture Capital Red Flag Checklist, investment firm website screenshot
Author
Bill Gurley
Publication date
November 28th, 2022
Difficulty
Intermediate
Keywords
  • corporate governance red flags
  • FTX bankruptcy
  • board of directors fiduciary duty
  • dual-class voting
  • audit waivers
  • unique financial metrics
  • secondary transactions
  • overlapping corporate interests
  • diligence checklist
Last update