How should we govern digital innovation? A venture capital perspective
Salgado-Criado, Mataix-Aldeanueva, Nardini, Lopez-Pablos, Balestrini, and Rosales-Torres use constructivist grounded theory, drawing on interviews with 23 venture capital investment managers, to characterize how investors actually perceive their own role in digital innovation governance, a topic they note has been extensively studied from societal, engineering, and policy perspectives but rarely from the investor community itself despite financing's critical role in shaping technology innovation. Analysis surfaces three categories investors weigh when deciding whether to engage: legitimacy of getting involved in a portfolio company's governance, opportunity to meaningfully conduct governance work, and capability to actually lead governance initiatives inside invested startups, with many VC managers describing digital innovation governance as something close to a fiduciary duty rather than an optional extra. The paper finds Environmental, Social, and Governance (ESG) frameworks function as an effective practical vehicle for this governance work, while AI-specific regulation tends to drive narrow compliance behavior rather than genuine governance engagement, and identifies a persistent lack of governance as a long-term inhibitor of business growth for the startups these investors back.
Why is relevant?
Founders building AI or other digitally intensive products get useful insight into how their investors actually think about governance oversight, since VCs describing this work as close to a fiduciary duty signals it is likely to come up in board conversations regardless of whether a founder proactively raises it. The three-part legitimacy, opportunity, and capability framework gives VCs themselves a genuinely structured self-assessment tool for deciding when and how to get involved in a portfolio company's digital innovation governance, rather than defaulting to either total hands-off deference or generic, uninformed intervention. The finding that AI-specific regulation drives compliance rather than genuine governance is a useful, somewhat counterintuitive data point for policymakers designing AI oversight rules, suggesting that regulatory frameworks alone may produce box-checking behavior unless paired with structures like ESG that investors already find genuinely actionable.

Author
Jesús Salgado-Criado, Carlos Mataix-Aldeanueva, Santiago Nardini, Cecilia López-Pablos, Mara Balestrini, César Said Rosales-Torres
Publication date
January 12th, 2024
Difficulty
Advanced
Keywords
- digital innovation governance
- AI governance
- ESG
- grounded theory
- VC fiduciary duty
- legitimacy opportunity capability
- AI regulation
- startup governance
Last update