Government venture capital funds: Balancing the impact of social and financial goals on startups
Li, Fung, and An study Chinese government venture capital funds (GVCs) against private (PVC) and foreign (FVC) venture funds using firms listed on the Shenzhen Growth Enterprise Market from 2009 to 2018, finding GVC-backed firms increase R&D investment, return on assets, and Tobin's Q more than firms backed only by private VC or left unbacked entirely, with GVC investment reaching $97 billion, the largest of any funding type, concentrated mostly in manufacturing. GVC-backed firms also increase corporate social responsibility spending, including corporate donations, employment-related, and environmental CSR, more than PVC-backed peers, supporting the argument that GVCs genuinely deliver on both the economic and explicit social policy goals the Chinese government set for them rather than functioning as inefficient political vehicles. GVC-backed firms attract more follow-on investment from other venture funds ahead of an eventual IPO than PVC or FVC-backed firms do, and also post a larger first-day IPO return, evidence the authors interpret as a signaling effect where a government fund's initial backing itself functions as a credibility marker that draws in additional capital and investor confidence.
Why is relevant?
Policymakers in other countries weighing whether to fund a government venture capital program get concrete, empirical evidence from China's large-scale experience that GVCs can genuinely outperform private VC on both financial and social outcomes simultaneously, a useful counterpoint to skepticism that state-backed VC inevitably underperforms or exists mainly for political optics. Founders evaluating a term sheet from a government-backed fund get a data-based reason to weigh the signaling value of that specific type of investor, since GVC backing is shown to attract more follow-on capital and produce stronger first-day IPO returns, a genuinely useful data point beyond assumptions about slower bureaucratic decision-making sometimes associated with state-affiliated investors. Researchers studying the broader global rise of sovereign and government venture vehicles get a rigorous empirical test case from the world's second-largest VC market, directly relevant to comparing China's approach against similar government fund models in Australia, France, Germany, Japan, and the UK mentioned in the paper's own framing.

Author
Jiu-Jin Li, Hung-Gay Fung, Shi An
Publication date
May 3rd, 2024
Difficulty
Advanced
Keywords
- government venture capital funds
- GVC
- R&D investment
- corporate social responsibility
- IPO signaling
- Shenzhen Growth Enterprise Market
- private venture capital
- foreign venture capital
- Tobin's Q
Last update