When venture capitalists are attracted by the experienced
Kim and Lee use conjoint analysis on 263 South Korean VCs, one of the largest samples in VC decision-making research, to test which entrepreneur characteristics matter most and how that weighting shifts under uncertainty, defined as high product newness and low product completeness. Educational background ranks as the single most important decision criterion at 22.44% relative importance, followed by industry experience at 19.24%, with managerial experience ranking last at just 6.49%, yet regression analysis shows uncertainty flips this ordering: as products become newer and less complete, VCs weight managerial experience significantly more heavily while weighting educational prestige significantly less. Industry experience, despite being highly valued overall, showed no significant relationship with uncertainty, meaning VCs do not lean on it more or less as risk increases, while the completeness of a product had the opposite effect from newness on educational background, making VCs value credentials more when a product is still incomplete but the underlying concept is not entirely novel.
Why is relevant?
Founders without an elite educational pedigree get a genuinely encouraging, evidence-based reason to lean harder on operational and managerial track record specifically when pitching a truly novel, unproven product, since the paper shows this is precisely the scenario where VCs shift weight away from credentials and toward hands-on management experience. The paper is also methodologically notable for using conjoint analysis on an unusually large sample of 263 VCs, addressing a longstanding data access problem in VC decision-making research, which makes it a useful reference for anyone designing similar experimental studies of investor judgment rather than relying on smaller convenience samples or self-reported surveys. The specific, counterintuitive finding that industry experience does not become more valued under uncertainty, unlike managerial experience, is a useful corrective for founders and researchers who might otherwise assume all forms of relevant experience become uniformly more important as a product gets riskier and less proven.

Author
Dohyeon Kim, Sang Yoon Lee
Publication date
June 24th, 2022
Difficulty
Advanced
Keywords
- conjoint analysis
- entrepreneur experience
- VC decision criteria
- educational background
- managerial experience
- industry experience
- product uncertainty
- Korean venture capital
- human capital theory
Last update